We are in a depression.
To be clear, this is not the “Great Depression” we have heard so much about from the 1930′s. We will not see 25% unemployment and we will not see massive bread lines. But that should not be the standard we hope to avoid. Our bar should be set much higher. Some might call this forecast more of a “Great Recession,” but I am going one step further due to the lack of growth that will come after this “Mini Depression” or whatever you prefer to call it technically ends.
While the definition of a depression may be elusive, we are looking at coming unemployment above 10% and an economy that will contract by around 3%-5% from peak-to-trough, maybe worse. 2009 will be negative in terms of growth by 2%-3%, maybe worse. Both the peak-to-trough number and the 2009 number would be worse if it weren’t for the government sectors ridiculous expansion. So these numbers could turn out to be worse, but this is what the data currently available tells me. We could deal with that, but what comes next is the real problem. Anemic growth caused by government policy will make a bad situation worse and we will stagnate. So even when it is technically over, it wont feel over. We will grow again in 2010, perhaps 2%, but the growth will be so weak that jobs will not follow and many will still feel recessionary pain. This depression most likely will not be an “L” shape, but it will resemble a square root thats been flipped horizontally like this “
.” The first line down represents the sudden drop our economy suffered. The small “V” shape that emerges next is the natural snap back rally that the stock market and economy will have. This could be worth 2500-3500 points on the DOW. What comes next is the flat line and economic stagnation.
I was hoping we would avoid it and merely suffer through a “U” shaped recession, but I am afraid to say the government has sealed our fate. In a shocking display of incompetence they have literally done everything wrong. President Obama and his team did not cause the recession, but they are causing the depression each and every day by their stunning stupidity. The hope that the Obama economic team would ease us to recovery with wonder boy tax cheat Tim Geithner steering the ship has totally evaporated.
Sure he did not pay his taxes, but since he was supposed to be brilliant, we were supposed to overlook his tax problems since he was supposed to help us. Yet, here we are and Geithner is on capital hill bashing energy companies and saying we need to tax them, saying we need to tax home mortage interest, saying we need to tax chairitable contributions, and saying we need to pay for national healthcare even though the government will spend around 2 trillion dollars more this year then they will take in.
We were told repeatedly by the media that this treasury secretary was brilliant and ready to step in on day one and hit the ground running. They said it was no big deal that he couldn’t figure out his own tax form. It was a simple mistake they said. This guy knew his stuff.
Uh oh! Here we are, no bank plan, nothing, nada, zero. The media lied to us or made a big mistake in their analysis. I don’t care which one, because the results are the same. If you would like an example of why there is no confidence in the leadership coming out of Washington DC, here it is.
The other day we had tax cheat Charlie Rangel questioning tax cheat Tim Geithner about, you guessed it, going after TAX CHEATS! I thought it was an Abbot and Costello routine when I watched it. Sadly, no one was laughing.
Unlike these two idiots, I actually pay my taxes so lets talk about it. I hear on a daily basis from supporters of Obama’s tax policy that “all he is doing is going back to the tax rates under Bill Clinton, and we had a great economy then.”
If anyone says this to you, you need to realize something about them. One possibility is they are idiots who have no idea what they are talking about. If they are in the financial world, never put money with them, never invest with them, and tell everyone you know to stay away from their financial advice. The other possibility is they are misleading you on purpose by not mentioning other factors due to their own ideological agenda. Why are they so wrong you ask?
First of all, in the 90′s we were blessed with the explosion of technology. This led to the tech bubble which sent the NASDAQ to 5000. Today it is around 1300. There is no tech bubble to bail us out this time. That bubble was so fierce that it overwhelmed the negative effects of higher taxes, but it was doomed to failure as we all know now. It burst and led us to the recession that George W. Bush inherited.
Second, we did not have the brutal international competition that we have today. Countries around the world are cutting taxes and enticing businesses to go there. This was unthinkable in the 90′s. The tax rates then in the USA were far better then most of the world. Today, it is the opposite. Today, communist China has lower taxes on capital and investments then the USA! I never thought I would envy the capital gains tax rates of a communist country, but here I am.
Third, in the 90′s we weren’t engaged in 2 brutal long wars and an over arching war on terror which has necessitated a rise in defense spending. Clinton did not have to worry about funding this so the budget never had to take massive military engagements into account. While Obama is not proposing massive increases to the current defense budget, he is not making massive cuts either because even he understands how high the stakes are and that our warriors need to be funded with the best equipment available.
Fourth, Mr. Obama and Mr. Geithner are not just talking about raising the top income rate from 35% to 39.6% we had under Clinton. The people who just wish to go back to the 90′s ignore the issues of social security taxes, medicare taxes, state taxes, property taxes, etc. I could go on and on. So rest assured, the high income earners who employ most everyone else will see their taxes rise to a total rate of far more then 39.6%.
So why would anyone compare the period during a tech bubble, peace time, and high tax rates around the world to today when we have a recession, massive deflation, low taxes around the world, higher taxes in the USA, and a staggering level of deficits that will add over 4 trillion dollars to the debt over Mr. Obama’s first term?
If you think your $500-$1000 check (Obama’s so called tax cut) from the government will help you, which is around $10-$20 a week, God bless you. However, you should know that this money will be devoured by inflation, higher energy prices, higher food prices, and higher local taxes. The great lie that 95% of Americans will get a tax cut is quite deceptive. If you think you fall into that 95% ask yourself a simple question. Do you use electricity? Do you drive a car? Do you eat? Do you buy anything? Do you save and invest for your retirement? If the answer is yes to any of these, then you will have your taxes raised whether you realize it or not.
Here is an example. The energy company that powers your house gets a huge carbon tax imposed on it. They still need to make a profit so they can maintain their service and pay their workers so they are forced to raise the electricity rates they charge you and your monthly bill goes up. Bang! You just got charged for Mr. Obama’s tax plan. But, you were in the 95%. You arent rich. So what happened?
Economic slight of hand happened and it is all too common in Washington DC.
Hopefully, you will hold onto your job, but then again the people that employ you will be getting hit with massive tax hikes that will be far more extensive then going from 35% to 39.6% as discussed earlier. When businesses and business owners make less profit, they have no choice but to limit costs and that means laying off workers.
Bottom line, we have a contracting economy that has imploded under a mountain of too much bad debt. Here is the solution the government has proposed.
*Endless bailouts of incompetant companies leading to nationalization in many cases
*Endless bailouts of people who bought homes they could not afford
*Higher taxes on the people who we want buying those very homes
*Higher taxes on businesses that we are asking to keep people employed
*Higher taxes on capital gains and dividends which by definition reduces the value of the stock market
*Higher taxes on home mortage interest
*Higher taxes on chairitable contributions
*Higher taxes on energy companies that every American relies on
*Trillions of dollars added to the national debt in the name of big government programs
We have a crisis of confidence where the professional investor and the average citizen both see Washington DC as totally out of touch. While we pull back and save money during the tough times, congress passes a bill with a $1.8 million earmark for “swine odor and manure management research.”
The DOW has fallen around 53% from its high, and it has fallen 31% since Mr. Obama was elected.
He did not cause the recession, but he is causing the depression. It makes me sick to say this. It hurts me deeply. I believe in the resilience of the American economy and the strength of our system, but even we cannot fight every battle all at once. If we do not change course, we will not be able to overcome this for a very long time. We are a rudderless ship in very stormy waters and unless the captain sets the right course we will be pummeled mercilessly by economic tidal waves for years.
I pray that I am wrong. Nothing would make me happier then to see a robust second half 2009 recovery, but I have no faith in that since I have no faith in the people who have the power to bring it about.